Current:Home > reviewsMedical pot user who lost job after drug test takes case over unemployment to Vermont Supreme Court -Streamline Finance
Medical pot user who lost job after drug test takes case over unemployment to Vermont Supreme Court
View
Date:2025-04-25 06:15:22
MONTPELIER, Vt. (AP) — A Vermont man who lost his job after he said a random drug test showed he had used medical marijuana off duty for chronic pain has appealed to the Vermont Supreme Court saying he should not have been denied a portion of his state unemployment benefits.
Ivo Skoric, 59, representing himself, told the justices Wednesday that he is legally prescribed the medical cannabis by a doctor and his work performance is excellent and not impacted by the medicine. Yet, he said, in January 2023 he was terminated from his job at the Marble Valley Regional Transit District in Rutland for misconduct after a drug test. He said his job was to clean and fuel buses, and he drove them into and out of the garage onto a lot. The misconduct disqualified him from the benefits, according to the state.
“As a medical cannabis patient in Vermont to treat disabling conditions under Vermont’s Fair Employment Practices Act disability provisions, I should be protected by state agencies. I should not be disqualified from receiving unemployment,” Skoric said.
A lawyer for the ACLU of Vermont, also representing Criminal Justice Reform, and Disability Rights Vermont, also argued that the benefits should not be denied.
Skoric had appealed to the Vermont Employment Security Board after he was found to be ineligible for state unemployment benefits for the weeks ending January 14, 2023, through February 18, 2023, and his maximum benefit amount was capped at 23 times his weekly benefit, according to the board.
In September 2023, the board agreed with an administrative law judge saying Skoric engaged in conduct prohibited by the employer’s drug and alcohol policy, “exposing him to discipline including termination of his employment,” and that because he was discharged for misconduct he was disqualified from those benefits.
The board wrote that it recognizes that Skoric engaged in conduct that is legal in Vermont and that he had “a legitimate and compelling reason to use medical cannabis for treatment.”
But “employers may set workplace policies that prohibit otherwise legal behavior,” the board wrote, saying that it agreed with the administrative judge that the minimum disqualification is appropriate.
The board later declined Skoric’s request for a declaratory ruling on whether the misconduct disqualification provision applied to the off-duty use of medical cannabis, which he asked the state Supreme Court to review.
Jared Adler, a lawyer representing the Vermont Department of Labor, said the court should affirm the board’s decision because he was discharged for misconduct for violating an acknowledged workplace safety policy and because “Vermont’s drug code does not guarantee unemployment benefits to people who test positive during a random drug screening.”
When asked by a justice if there’s a distinction between consumption and impairment Adler said there is but “there’s no clean way” for an employer to distinguish between consumption and impairment in the case of cannabis because, unlike other drugs, it can exist for an extended period of time in an individual’s system after consuming it. Skoric also said that even though he had used the medical cannabis off-duty, it can show up days later in someone’s system, which makes the testing meaningless.
There’s a balancing test for trying to protect both the public and an employer’s need to conform their policies with federal law, Adler said. Skoric acknowledged his employer received up to 60% of their funding for their business from federal grants, Alder said.
So it was extremely important to ensure that the employer adhere to these federal rules and not risk losing that revenue, Adler said.
Skoric said his position is that “off-duty use of cannabis for state-sanctioned medical purposes cannot and should not be qualified as misconduct by the state.”
“I should not have to choose between state benefits and the medical care (the) state granted me to use,” he said. “I should never be put in that impossible position to choose between benefits and the legal medicine I use.”
veryGood! (392)
Related
- Sam Taylor
- These tiny worms live in eyes, feed on tears and could transmit to humans
- Amid Matthew Perry arrests, should doctors be blamed for overdose deaths?
- Jack Russell, former Great White frontman, dies at 63
- The Daily Money: Disney+ wants your dollars
- Man who pulled gun after Burger King worker wouldn’t take drugs for payment gets 143 years in prison
- Rail bridge collapses on US-Canada border
- Neighbor reported smelling gas night before Maryland house explosion
- Kentucky Gov. Andy Beshear ready to campaign for Harris-Walz after losing out for spot on the ticket
- How Rumer Willis Is Doing Motherhood Her Way
Ranking
- Billy Bean was an LGBTQ advocate and one of baseball's great heroes
- Watch as the 1,064-HP 2025 Chevy Corvette ZR1 rips to 205 MPH
- US prosecutors aim to try Mexican drug lord ‘El Mayo’ Zambada in New York, then in Texas
- Prominent 2020 election denier seeks GOP nod for Michigan Supreme Court race
- Where will Elmo go? HBO moves away from 'Sesame Street'
- Ryan Reynolds Reacts to Deadpool's Box Office Rivalry With Wife Blake Lively's It Ends With Us
- Jury begins deliberations in trial of white Florida woman in fatal shooting of Black neighbor
- Trans teens file lawsuit challenging New Hampshire law banning them from girls’ sports
Recommendation
Tom Holland's New Venture Revealed
AP Week in Pictures: Global
Honolulu mayor vows tougher approach on homelessness
Lawyer and family of U.S. Air Force airman killed by Florida deputy demand that he face charges
The FTC says 'gamified' online job scams by WhatsApp and text on the rise. What to know.
Asteroids safely fly by Earth all the time. Here’s why scientists are watching Apophis.
Why Fans Think Taylor Swift Made Cheeky Nod to Travis Kelce Anniversary During Eras Tour With Ed Sheeran
Michael Brown’s death transformed a nation and sparked a decade of American reckoning on race